Category: Apologetics

Seven More Books for Catholic College Students
0

Seven More Books for Catholic College Students

by

The college semester is upon us again, and at most universities the new academic year is either now beginning or has recently begun [1]. For the returning students, this means a return to familiar stomping grounds and reunions with friends before the courses really buckle down into the semester grind. For the new students, it […]

The Assumption of Mary for Converts and non-Catholics
0

The Assumption of Mary for Converts and non-Catholics

by

Mary was assumed into heaven. It’s one of the more difficult teachings for converts to grasp. But there are ways to approach the Assumption so that non-Catholics may come to believe. In 1995, I wrote an article for Protestant newspapers called “Trends in Christian Fiction” which considered the possibility that a Christian fiction book might […]

Are Protestant Communities "Churches"?
63

Are Protestant Communities “Churches”?

by

In our last article, we demonstrated how Dr. Alan Schreck, as many orthodox Catholics do, erroneously applies the hermeneutic of discontinuity to the use of the terms “heresy” and “heretic” before Vatican II and the non-use of those terms in the Council. We will now do likewise with the term “church” as it was used […]

The Bad Evangelist Club:  Sola Scriptura and the "Essentials"?
1

The Bad Evangelist Club: Sola Scriptura and the “Essentials”?

by

One common response that Protestants will use to defend or explain away their clear disunity in doctrine is by retreating into the dichotomy dogma, which they call the essentials of the faith, versus non-essentials of the faith.  Their defense begins like this, ‘Our unity is found in that all true Christian churches agree on the […]

Continuity & Ecumenism:  Heretics or Seperated Brethren?
26

Continuity & Ecumenism: Heretics or Seperated Brethren?

by

While writing my self-published manuscript, New Things and Old: Re-Implementing Vatican II, I came to the realization that Vatican II could only be understood in light of past magisterial teaching and the sources of the Tradition.  Taken by themselves the documents could lead even orthodox Catholics to formulate or embrace conclusions that were erroneous and […]

Fatal Errors with Sola Scriptura's "God Breathed" Argument
47

Fatal Errors with Sola Scriptura’s “God Breathed” Argument

by

Ezekiel and I agreed on just about everything, except for theology and football. He was a dogmatic Calvinist and a Pittsburgh Steelers fanatic (which is different than just being a ‘fan’). He was also an awesome debater and very logical – a bit loud and hyperbolic – but his gift was never being able to […]

Two Josephs, Both Alike in Chastity
5

Two Josephs, Both Alike in Chastity

by

With our attention upon St. Joseph today, it might be good to look back at the Old Testament figure for whom Mary’s chaste spouse was most likely named. That would be Joseph, son of Jacob, grandson of Isaac, and great-grandson of Abraham. Joseph is a popular name for Jewish boys precisely as a memorial of this […]

What Can Screwtape Teach Us About Discipleship?
0

What Can Screwtape Teach Us About Discipleship?

by

“By faith man completely submits his intellect and his will to God” (Dei Verbum, 5). Our Screwtape Tendency You may be wondering how the Screwtape Letters can possibly help us in becoming better disciples. If we take the time to carefully dissect what Screwtape’s intent is with the “Patient”, we see the very thing Screwtape is […]

Lenten Reflection: What Is Salvation?
0

Lenten Reflection: What Is Salvation?

by

Shortly before his martyrdom, St. Paul penned a letter to his friend Timothy. The great apostle seems to have known that death was near, and his bittersweet words are imbued with a sense of urgency. St. Paul comforts and commends his young protégé, while exhorting him to sacrifice. “Do not be ashamed of the testimony […]

The Romance of Religion
0

Book Review: The Romance of Religion by Dwight Longenecker

by

Ever “evolving”, “progressing” — or so he believes — the modern intellectual mentality slithers out of the sea of mystery, clambering from arrogant skepticism to jaded cynicism, until exhausted of wit and verve, it reaches the hard shore of “reason”.  And there on the flat landscape it flutters, just out of reach of the lapping […]

Escaping the Catholic Church Through False Justification
11

Escaping the Catholic Church Through False Justification

by

Eve knew very well what God had commanded her and Adam, but the text tells us that she had found the tree of knowledge of good and evil good to be pleasing to the eyes and desirable for gaining wisdom (Cf. Gen 3:6). It doesn’t take a whole lot for us to find justification to […]

We are the Light of the Word
0

We are the Light of the Word

by

“Jesus is the greatest treasure in the universe. Jesus is better than anything—even the Super Bowl. If you have Jesus, it’s still awesome, whether you win or lose.” In a recent television interview, Rocky Seto, a coach for the Seattle Seahawks, the NFL champions of Super Bowl 48, expressed his belief that faith in Jesus […]

The Bad Evangelist Club:  How NOT to Refute Sola Scriptura
52

The Bad Evangelist Club: How NOT to Refute Sola Scriptura

by

When discussing the arguments against Sola Scriptura, we Catholics have a lot of strong arguments.  Here at The Bad Evangelist Club, we help you to avoid bad arguments like the one below so the good ones have more credibility. The Argument Any debate around Sola Scriptura will focus on 2 Timothy 3:14-17, which goes as […]

A Whale of an Argument
51

A Whale of an Argument

by

Have you heard the argument against the existence of God based on the size of the universe? You might find it strange that an argument against God would be constructed based on the enormity of space — something that elicits awe and wonder. But it is, and it goes like this: You see how big the […]

The Bad Evangelist Club:  33,000 Denominations
122

The Bad Evangelist Club: 33,000 Denominations

by

*Editor Note:  Starting this month we will be introducing a new series at Catholic Lane.  Known as The Bad Evangelist Club, we will be providing an examination of conscience so to speak for Catholic efforts at Evangelization and Apologetics.  We will do so by reflecting on the bad arguments being made (often by the writers […]

By What Authority - Carousel
0

Book Review: By What Authority by Mark Shea

by

Resolve to read “By What Authority?” in 2014.

Christmas Tree, Vatican City, 2011
1

Jeremiah, Christmas Trees, and the King James Bible

by

Responding to an annual fundamentalist canard.

Refuting the Myth of the "Invisible Church"
0

Refuting the Myth of the “Invisible Church”

by

After they rejected the hierarchical Catholic Church, one of the early tasks of the protestant reformulators was to redefine what Church is; more precisely, to define the visible nature of the New Covenant community of God’s chosen people. It being clear to them through sacred Scripture that Christ Jesus actually did established a Church; they […]

Catholics and Private Revelation Part II:  The Voice of Tradition
0

Catholics and Private Revelation Part II: The Voice of Tradition

by

Recently, there was some discussion on the topic of private revelation in an article recently posted to Catholic Lane. I want at this time to point to some additional information that is not commonly known which will help shed some light on why the spiritual writers of the Catholic tradition as well as the Catechism […]

Why You Should Receive Communion Kneeling and on the Tongue
47

Why You Should Receive Communion Kneeling and on the Tongue

by

In the 13 years I have been a practicing Catholic, I have been a traditionalist all but two of them.  As a result, I have received communion on the tongue and kneeling for eleven years.  I’ve also found that the way we traditionalists receive communion is something that many Catholics outside of the Extraordinary Form […]

We Must Evangelize
19

We Must Evangelize

by

It’s the great dilemma for Catholics. We know that we are to share Christ. We are to go into the highways and byways and even into the Internet superhighway and tell the world about Jesus Christ and His Church. But we don’t know what to do about that troublesome word: proselytizing. Evangelism is good. Proselytizing is bad. […]

Taking the Bible Seriously
0

Taking the Bible Seriously

by

I remember during my dating days wanting to start a Bible study with a girl I was dating.  She liked the idea, but asked “which commentary are we going to use in studying the Bible?”  Puzzled, I said we wouldn’t be.  We would just talk over the phone/in person about various Bible verses, what they […]

Is Peter the Rock?
0

Is Peter the Rock?

by

One of the most hotly-contested passages in Catholic-Protestant dialogues is the “Upon This Rock” passage in Matthew 16:18. After the Apostle Simon confesses faith in Jesus as the Messiah (the Christ), Jesus says to him “And I tell you, you are Peter, [Petros] and on this rock [petra] I will build my church, and the powers of death [Hades] shall not prevail […]

Egyptian Muslim questions Christianity.  A Catholic replies.
14

Egyptian Muslim questions Christianity. A Catholic replies.

by

The following interview/discussion took place between Abdallah and me from October 6-8, 2013.  Abdallah is my Facebook friend from Cairo, Egypt. He is a software engineer and a supporter of the restoration of President Morsi.  We met via the chat feature of an online chess program.  (Published with Abdallah’s approval). Abdallah:  Many times I keep […]

Page 1 of 712345...Last »