Limits on Children’s Media Exposure
ANALYSIS/OPINION:
From this week’s e-mail, a message from a dad whose ex-wife doesn’t share his concerns about the influence of the culture on their high schooler and preteens:
To: Marybeth
From: A concerned dad
How do you suggest defending against the culture’s assault on childhood when it starts coming via an “inside job”? My soon-to-be ex previously saw and resisted it, but in recent years has pretty much switched rather than fight.
For example, it bothers me that she lets our high schooler play games with unacceptable content (violence and sexual themes), and allows the younger ones to hang out and observe. I’d solve both problems by limiting what the older one can play, both for his own good and to eliminate the younger ones’ exposure. Her view: Other kids play (and do) things that are a lot worse.
Concerning Facebook, I wouldn’t allow a child on it at all until about age 17, and only then with some careful oversight and limits. Her view is that this is how kids stay in touch these days, and do I want them to have friends or not?
I don’t want to do anything that criticizes their mom to my kids or undermines their relationship; she’s a good person and she’s their mom. But I also think exposure to the excesses of video games, the Internet, etc., is harmful. I’d appreciate any thoughts on how to walk that line.
To: Concerned
From: Marybeth
I’ll start with the most obvious and important aspect of your message — the fact that your marriage is breaking up has and will continue to have an impact on the way in which you and your ex-wife parent your children. Sadly, serious disagreements about parenting can be among the most destructive to a marriage. At the very least, a faltering marriage would bring these conflicts to light, as you’ve discovered. It’s worth the time and effort to find as much common ground as possible in your parenting decisions.
On the other hand, if your children’s mother formerly shared your concerns about the culture’s influence on the kids, she may be less concerned now because issues around your dissolving marriage are more pressing and important. And of course, that’s true. But what’s also true is that the negative influences of the culture have a greater chance of impact on teens and adolescents who are undergoing the upheaval that your children are experiencing because of your impending divorce.
First and foremost, I hope you have done (and are still doing) everything in your power to rescue your marriage. Your best hope of having greater influence on the ways in which your children engage with the culture is to remain “inside” and do the job together.
If your marriage can’t be saved, then you’ll have to create in your separate home an environment with respect to cultural engagement that you think is best. Establish rules for your house that reflect your values and use the time there to expose the children to the kinds of media and activities that you feel are more wholesome and appropriate.
Expect resistance since your home will feel stricter, so lay out your rules in a loving, constructive way. Say, “I know you’re allowed to play certain games and be on Facebook when you’re at Mom’s, but I’d like to do things a little differently when you’re here. I’m going to limit gaming choices and put some limits on media time so we can make the most of our time together,” or something like that.
Keep this in mind: The culture is a fact of life in this era. We who consider ourselves “conservative” or “traditional” in values must recognize that we can’t influence our children by only saying no (though often that’s absolutely what must be said). We have to be out there setting an example and demonstrating that we don’t have to be swayed by everything we encounter in the culture, but rather, that we’re capable of making choices about how and when we engage in it that reflect our values and the character we want for families.
